Unshackled ~ An Ex-Amish Woman’s Testimony

Dear Readers,

Last week, I received this message from a young woman who read The Outcast . She had grown up in the Amish church but left under the protection of her family when she was nineteen years old. This is what she had to say:

I remember the intense attraction the other church people had about this girl who was shunned. They wanted to hear about her sins, and her shortcomings. They would gasp in shock at the terrible things she was supposedly doing. I would sometimes look at her, in her eyes, and see fierce determination and pride, and yet an almost nauseous look of hurt. She did not defend herself or engage in the gossip. There were a couple of times in reading The Outcast that I felt like I could not breathe for the pain that Rachel was feeling. I think I know now what my friend went through. Your book was so authentic, the German words, Rachel’s loving yet harsh mother. It felt like more than a book to me.

Over that day and the next, this young woman (who wishes to remain anonymous) and I communicated. Soon, we went from writer to reader to lifelong friends. I was so honored when she not only agreed to an interview about her experience in the Amish church, but felt like she had a message that needed to be shared.

Without further ado, I present to you one of the most resilient young women I have ever met. She is a testament to the difference between legalism and righteousness and the power of God’s true love.


Unshackled From The Amish Church

Thank you so much for sharing your story today. I know that you would like to remain anonymous, and I greatly appreciate you reaching beyond your comfort zone to let others, who have left the Amish church, know that they are not alone.

What was your favorite memory during your time in the Amish community?

My favorite memory was all the fun I had as a child. Our life was very gentle and innocent. I had a pony, and my brothers and sisters were my very best friends. I loved working with my brothers outside, and they always treated me as if I were one of their favorite people.

You said that you lost your friends twice: once during a church split, and then again when you left. How old were you when the church split took place?

I was eleven when the first church split happened. I was too young to fully grasp what was going on, and could not understand why all my cousins and some of my friends were just taken from my life. It felt like I had experienced the death of most of my friends. It took me quite a while to make really close friends again, but it did happen. My family left the Amish when I was nineteen. Again, I lost pretty much every single friend I had, plus all of my cousins. I realized that day that I was only loved for the clothes I wore, and the religion I professed to believe in. I realized then that nobody except my own family loved me for me. It was my kapp, my dress, the pins in my halsduh (cape) that they loved.

How did this affect your growing up years?

I learned to walk away from relationships at the first sign of danger. And for a long time, I held almost everybody at arm’s length. I had a mindset that I was not worthy of any kind of real relationships until I met my husband, and after ten years of being married, he is convincing me that I am worth it to him.

Did you stay in the same area when you and your family left the community?

Yes, we did, although my parents’ families begged us to move to alleviate their shame. I know it would have been much easier for my parents to move, and it would have even eventually restored their relationships with their families, but they did not back down. And for that, I respect them enormously. It would have been a lot easier on us, too, if they had moved. But I think it would have taught us to give up, and that we do not do. We are not quitters. Not a single one of us.

How did the family still within the Amish church treat you when they saw you?

Sometimes my aunts would cry when they saw us. They would beg my parents to return to the fold. They would turn their backs in stores and quickly hurry away, pretending they had not seen us. They hurt my parents often, and for a while I became quite bitter about it. People said terrible things about my parents and told me they pitied me.

Have you since reconnected with those who have also left the Amish church?

Yes, I have. I have met many sweet ladies who have also walked away from the only way of life they have ever known. Some of them are still known in their communities as “the bad one,” but I see their lovely hearts which long after the Lord, and I wish that the people who loved them before would be able to see them now as they shine with the relief of forgiveness from the terrible burden of sin. My very own husband is one of these. But now when I hear from others, and even his own family of his old sin, I can just laugh with delight and I tell them they do not know the man I know!

Is it bittersweet to recall the times within the community?

It’s very bittersweet. When I start to reminisce, I always end up in tears of sadness that my sweet little girlfriends are not even known to me anymore. I don’t know their children or their husbands. It’s very, very hard sometimes. I still love them intensely. When I was small, I loved with innocent abandon. I will never forget my sweet little girlfriends. Those memories are so sweet. But not being in their life now, is a bitter pill.

What are the aspects of your Amish heritage that you and your family cherish?

The importance of family, and the importance of marriage. My parents have a wonderful marriage, and my mom taught me to honor my husband no matter what. It’s good to have a simple way of life.

What aspects of your heritage are you grateful to leave behind?

I am so grateful to leave behind the belief that one must earn one’s salvation. I am saved. The work is done; my sin has been taken from me as far as the east is from the west. I am free! This is so overwhelming to me and almost incomprehensible. I also do not miss the straight pins, the kapp, the awful belt I had to wear, the gossip, the rites and rituals and so much more. . . .

Is there anything you would like to share with those who may have also gone through the shunning or left the church?

Yes, I sure would. Stand up, ladies and gentlemen, and do not be afraid anymore. Only fear God. Do not fear man. Do not try to please people because people will not be pleased. Not ever. It’s not possible! Only fear the Lord, and He will give you wisdom and you will be used above and beyond what you ever dreamed! My husband and I constantly compare our first inclinations, our first feelings, our first thoughts, with Scripture to see whether they are actually the way it is, or just the way we were taught from little up from a religious point of view. Open your hearts to people. Do not become bitter. Allow yourself to trust and love again. . . .

Thank you so much, my friend, for being here today. I am honored to know you. Beyond that, I have no more words. Just gratitude.

(Image from Breaking Amish)


  1. A gorgeous interview! Thanks so much to you both for sharing this!

    • Brave Young Woman did all of the work; so honored by her willingness to share her story! And thank you for stopping by, Lisa! :)

    • Dear Jolina,

      I left a legalistic cult in Illinois in 2008. I have struggled with guilt, shame, confusion, and anger for the last six years since. But The Lord has led me to this interview showing me that I’m still His beloved in His Son Jesus. The Lord has blessed me with a beautiful; wife and son since I moved to New Mexico and serving in the state government and sharing my faith with others.
      I left this culty church for the same reasons you left the Amish community. I am moved by your compassion and God’s grace giving you the freedom to forgive the people who hurt you and your family. The Lord is moving me on the path of a steady recovery from this past experience. In Christ, I am a new creation and He makes all things new.

      • Indeed He does make all things new, Mark. I actually was never part of the Amish or Mennonite church, but my family — during my childhood — were also “shunned” while still remaining inside a Christian community. We lost almost everything but God saw us through and made us stronger because of it. I’m glad you and your family have found healing and redemption as well. Blessings to you all!

  2. What a heartbreaking – but empowering – post. I’m so glad you shared it, Jolina and Brave Young Woman (that’s what I’ll call your anonymous guest). I see a lot of similarities regarding the gossip and the superficiality of religion spoken of her – to my own Evangelical upbringing. We were only deemed good if we followed a set of rules, and we also had to earn our salvation.

    Again – thanks for sharing this touching post of resilience.

  3. You are so welcome, Melissa. Brave Young Woman is such an example to me. I often care too much what others think (especially now the The Outcast’s in “review” time), and it’s so true that we cannot care what others think of us, only that God does.

  4. I welcomed this real but heartrending glimpse into the Amish/not-Amish world. I live in the Northwest, where there is very little exposure to Amishness. Why do you suppose there’s not more conversation in the Christian community Amish legalism? Why is that way of life so glorified in Amish fiction? The Outcast is the exception, at least in what I’ve seen. Maybe I’m just not listening to the right conversations, but it seems to me there should be more Christians talking about this. Would love your thoughts.

  5. Hello, dear Katherine! It’s always such a pleasure to see you here. Honestly, I think that most bonnet fiction readers want to read for escapism. We live in a sad, heartbreaking world, and it’s a comfort to perceive the Anabaptist (Amish, Mennonite, Hutterite) communities as the last standing Utopia, if you will. Unfortunately, as Brave Young Girl revealed, these communities struggle with sin just like the rest of us. By continuing to shield this sin, it almost condones it. I hope The Outcast is a balance between truth and compassion, and that Amish fiction readers will see the communities in a true light that has the power to overcome darkness.

  6. A balance between truth and compassion. That’s exactly how I found The Outcast, what made it appeal to me so greatly. Thank you for these insights as well. You help to increase my understanding.

  7. Brave Young Woman increased my understanding as well. We’re all in this together!

  8. Emma Troyer Glaeser says:

    While reading this I felt you were interviewing me; I to left the Amish 28 years ago and can relate to what she was saying. I married an awesome man of God whom is not from the Amish background and at times does not understand how your own blood can turn their back on you, but over the years of seeing my pain has learned to just be there for me with open arms and a kind heart towards my family and that is all I can ask of him! Ultimately I know God is in control and that is good enough for me. He catches my tears of sadness and loves me through it all.

    Thank you for sharing.


    • Oh, Emma! I’m so sorry for the pain that you have gone through. Pray that you too have been able to connect with others who have experienced what you have. You are worthy of God’s love, and even if man “shuns” you, this does not change His pleasure in who you are! Hugs to you, friend!

  9. Patricia A. Spayd says:

    How can any community of God misinterpret – in any language – the words of Paul in Ephesians 2:8 – “Because it is by grace that you have been saved, through faith, not by anything of your own, but by a gift from God;” Not clothing, not horse, or no horse, by rims of metal, or rims of rubber, nothing, not our good deeds and keeping a list of those deeds. Auf Deutscher “Die Bibel” gesagt Epheser 2:8: “denn aus Gnade seid ihr durch den Glauben gerettet, nicht aufgrund eurer Werke,damit keuner sich ruehmen kann.”

  10. Michele Musgrove says:

    Hi Jolina, I am so glad to hear of your faith in Christ and how HE has set you free. I like many other Christians have romanticized the Amish Community believing it to be peaceful and simplistic, and loving. It has only been in recent years that I have come to understand that Amish beliefs are based on works. This makes me so sad and I would like to help. We live in Clarksville, Tn. which is just miles away from some Amish communities in Southern Kentucky. I know of no churches in our area that are reaching out to this community. How could I help? I have seen documentaries of people leaving everything when they leave the church and having to start over with nothing. I would like to know how I could reach out or approach local churches. Thank you for your time,

    • Hello, Michele, I actually used to live near Clarksville, TN, so I know exactly where you are. :) I was never raised Amish–this guest post was written by a friend of mine–but I do agree that a majority of the Amish belief is based on works. However, I’ve also had the pleasure of meeting those who have a true relationship with God. Mission to the Amish People is a great ministry that would help you get plugged into various communities. http://www.mapministry.org


  1. […] people are genuinely interested when I talk about how The Outcast is ministering to those who are no longer part of their Amish or Mennonite communities, and yet they don’t fully belong in our Englisher (non-Amish) world […]

Speak Your Mind